Results 1 to 2 of 2

Thread: The Suicide of Harley Davidson

  1. #1
    Vulture of The Western World Eric's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2006
    Location
    The Land of The Edentulites
    Posts
    22,732

    The Suicide of Harley Davidson

    Imagine a Harley that doesn’t vibrate. No bark through the straight pipes when you push the starter button. No nothing through the pipes - which aren't there anymore.
    There is no starter button.
    Just an On/Off switch.
    No shifter, either. Because no gears.
    All that remains is the "Harley" name on the tank - which isn't one because it will never be used to store any gas. Might as well paint it on the side of your toaster.
    Welcome to the 2019 LiveWire - Harley’s first electric motorcycle. The first of a whole line of them - intended to be ready by 2025.
    They’re betting the future of the company on it.
    If you have any Harley stock, better unload it.
    Quickly.
    Because an electric Harley is as silly as juice-bar speakeasy. It runs counter to the point.
    People buy motorcycles - and especially Harley motorcycles - because they make that sound.
    And also because of the smells - of gas and oil - which attend those sounds. Without which you've got what amounts to alcohol-free beer.
    Or a girlfriend who won't sleep with you.
    There is no engineering reason for the distinctive - and patented - potato-potato-potato sound which for decades has defined the presence of a Harley before you even see the Harley.
    And it is the heart and soul of a Harley.
    That sound was actually the result of a design flaw inherent in the early versions of the big V-twins - but became iconic. It is why that sound has been deliberately perpetuated - built in - as the V-twin engine was redesigned and updated over the years.
    The company actually sued other bike manufacturers who built their bikes to emulate the rowdy sound of a Hog (and then sold their knock-off Hogs for a lot less).
    What is a Harley without that sound? Think of Arnold without his muscles - or his accent.
    And without everything else that makes not just a Harley, but a motorcycle?
    This thing goes on two wheels. That is the only thing it has in common with motorcycles. It is, fundamentally, a Moped - but lacking even the Moped's internal combustion burble at idle. The operating principles are essentially identical.
    One does not ride this bike; one is carried along for the ride.
    You get on, turn it on - and that's pretty much it. There's nothing for your left hand to do except grip the bar, there being no clutch. Your legs - your feet - have even less to do than in an automatic-equipped car.
    No gears to shift, remember. An electric bike has no transmission, no speeds or gears. The only thing you do on this "bike" that you'd do on a real one is rotate the throttle to increase speed.
    They've taken away more than just the sound.
    There's a brake pedal on the right side, true enough. But this bike has electrically linked (and ABS) brakes, so squeezing the right lever is all you need to do to slow it down. The rear brake cannot be modulated independently (they - the same people pushing the electric Kool Aid - are trying to eliminate this possibility on real bikes, too; see here) and so the existence of the pedal on this bike is purely vestigial.
    But the LIveWire will have an adjustable LCD color touchscreen, Bluetooth and navigation.
    Just like every other sail fawn on wheels, whether two or four.
    And, just wait. Literally.
    Like electric cars, the electric Harley takes anywhere from hours to recharge to as "little" as half an hour or so, if you plug it in to a "fast" charger. Harley has announced it will be installing these at dealerships, to "support" the electric gimpmobiles.
    This is not going to end well. For the intangible reasons already articulated - a BLT without the bacon - and for other more tangible reasons.
    Harleys - more than any other make of bike - appeal to the cruiser. The long-haul rider. The open road.
    But electric bikes - like electric cars - are stunted by abbreviated operational range. A 2019 V-twin Sport Glide carries 5 gallons of easily and quickly replaced gas and gets 47 MPG. It thus can travel almost 240 miles - and when the tank runs low, this Harley can be back on the road in minutes.
    That is freedom.
    With the LiveWire, you are tied to an electric umbilical cord.
    The opposite of freedom.
    Note also that the LiveWire is a very small bike - a stripped-down "naked" electro-sport bike - in order to squeeze as much range out of the thing as possible.
    But people who buy Harleys don't buy sport bikes. It runs contrary to the point. People who buy Hogs want heavyweights. They want to be able to carry passengers and bags - all of which takes power, which a big V-twin can easily deliver but an electric motor not so much.
    At least, not with much range.
    Even IC-powered sport bike Harleys flopped (Buell). Now add electricity - and watch the fizzle.
    It'd be funny if it weren't so tragic.
    So why is Harley is resorting this electric selbsmordt?
    It is because it is in trouble . . . but it is in trouble because its bikes cost too much relative to other bikes - almost all of which are made in Japan - and sold for much less. For the $10k minimum it takes to get a stripped-down/base model 1200 HD you can buy a Japanese copy of the same thing and have a lot more money left in your pocket.
    Only a small handful of Japanese bikes sticker for more than $20k. But that's just getting rolling for a dresser Hog - the price of which can easily sail beyond $30k.
    Harley is not in trouble because its bikes aren't electric. There is no natural demand for such things - although there is plenty of of government demand (Harley, like every other manufacturer of IC-powered vehicles - is going EV because it being forced to go EV by the government).
    Lots of people would love to own a Hog; they just can't afford one.
    And they won't be able to afford an electrified HD.
    Which will never be a Hog, either.
    This is the fundamental economic problem with all electric vehicles, two wheels or four.
    They cost too much. It is why they can only "sell" when subsidized (wait).
    Harley had not released LiveWire pricing info when this article was written in early November of 2018 - so we don't know the fulsome scurvy details, yet. But - to date - everything electrified has cost substantially more than its non-electric equivalent.
    To get some idea of what this electro-Harley will cost, we can refer to the known prices of the other electric bike already on the market. It is the Zero, available in several different versions.
    The Zero S is a "naked' middleweight bike just barely comparable to a middleweight naked/sport bike from the 1980s of around 500 ccs (its engine makes about 60 hp and the top speed of this bike is only a bit more than 100 MPH; most non-electric current-year middleweights have close to 100 hp can be counted on to hit at least 140).
    The S stickers for $13,995 (with the "upgrade" battery that gives you 90 miles of highway range) which is about $5,000 more than you'd pay for a current 650-ish cc naked/middleweight sport bike.
    Of course, Harley is counting on the government to "help."
    There are incentives - taxpayer-extorted palm greasing - for the buyers of electric bikes, just as there are for electric cars. $900 in California; $1,440 in Maryland.
    Even if you don't ride an electric bike, you'll still be forced to buy one . . . for someone else.
    Just like Teslas.
    That's the new business model in these waning days of the empire.
    It's too bad for Harley. And it's too bad for us.
    . . .
    Got a question about cars - or anything else? Click on the "ask Eric" link and send 'em in!
    If you like what you've found here please consider supporting EPautos.
    We depend on you to keep the wheels turning!
    Our donate button is here.
    If you prefer not to use PayPal, our mailing address is:
    EPautos
    721 Hummingbird Lane SE
    Copper Hill, VA 24079





    PS: Get an EPautos magnet (pictured below) in return for a $20 or more one-time donation or a $5 or more monthly recurring donation. (Please be sure to tell us you want a sticker - and also, provide an address, so we know where to mail the thing!)
    My latest eBook is also available for your favorite price - free! Click here.



  2. #2
    Senior Member DonTom's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2009
    Location
    Auburn, CA & Reno, NV & Cold Springs Valley, NV
    Posts
    663
    Is it really the cost of a Harley? How is BMW doing these days with their cycle sales?

    BTW, I now own a 2017 Harley Road Glide Ultra with the M-8. The story on this engine is interesting. When first designed, Harley felt it was too smooth, so they went from a 100% balanced engine to 75% balanced. But can a touring bike really be too smooth?

    Also, the Livewire, as first designed was way too quiet. So they introduced some phony noise.

    I have my doubts if these were good ideas. People do not buy touring bikes to make their nuts shake. And people do not buy electric bikes because they make noise.

    Perhaps it's other reasons why Harley has not been doing so well.

    Perhaps they should try harder for the non-Harley Market. Imagine a Honda GoldWing owner discovering his six cylinder bike is not as smooth and quiet as a Harley touring bike.

    If Harley isn't doing well, perhaps they should make a few changes. Perhaps the price isn't the problem. Seems BMW doesn't worry much about their prices and neither do their customers.

    -Don- Auburn, CA

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •