Diesel Pros… and Cons

Print Friendly

Diesel-powered vehicles are making a big comeback – no surprise given renewed buyer interest in high-efficiency, long-life vehicles. But like gas-burners, diesels have their downsides as well as their upsides.

Here’s a look at both sides of the equation: 

Pros:

* Excellent fuel economy – with excellent performance -

Many people remember the days when “diesel” meant “slow.” But modern diesel engines such as those offered by VW (Jetta TDI) and BMW (330d) and Mercedes (E350 BlueTec) can deliver 40-plus MPGs – not far off the pace of complex, expensive and slow gas-electric hybrids – while getting the cars they’re in to 60 mph in as little as 7 seconds.

In a large truck such as the current GM 2500 HD series or Ford F250, diesel-equipped versions can pull/haul much more weight than the gas-powered versions while burning less fuel doing it.

* Diesel engines are typically longer lived than gasoline-burning engines - 

Assuming proper maintenance, it is not unusual for a diesel engine to run 300,000 miles or more without needing major work. Even though modern gas engines generally last much longer than they used to, few can go more than 200,000 miles or so without beginning to show definite signs of wear and tear, such as smoky blue exhaust and declining gas mileage/performance.

* Diesels can burn more than one type of fuel -

For example, old fry grease – aka Waste Vegetable Oil (WVO). Frugally-minded people have been powering their diesel vehicles with this stuff at little or no cost by getting local restaurants and so on to give it to them for free. Modifications to the engine (such as a preheater to keep the grease from congealing) will be needed, but you can operate a diesel engine with such stuff in a pinch.

“Biodiesel” (not the same as WVO) can be brewed at home, too.

Gas engines, meanwhile, are designed to burn gas only. And you can’t refine your own gas, if it came to that. 

Cons:

* Diesel fuel is now more expensive than gasoline -

New federal laws mandating “Ultra Low Sulfur” fuel (15 PPM sulfur) have jacked-up the price per gallon of diesel, which is still close to $3 per gallon in most areas of the country, while unleaded regular is often available for closer to $2.30 or so. The higher at-the-pump price eats into the down-the-road mileage advantage that diesels have.

Another potential problem with the new Ultra Low Sulfur diesel fuel is that it doesn’t have the same lubricating qualities (due to the low sulfur content) as diesel fuel used to have, which could mean faster wear and tear – and shorter engine life. Some diesel engine experts recommend that additives (http://www.powerservice.com/dfs/5) be used – especially in diesel engines built before about 1997 – to make up for the poorer lubricating qualities of the new Ultra Low Sulfur diesel fuel.    

* Diesel engines now have cost (and hassle) adding anti-pollution equipment - 

In addition to Ultra Low Sulfur diesel fuel, the car companies have had to add urea injection and particulate traps to their diesel engines, in order to comply with the latest tailpipe emissions requirements. The urea tanks have to be refilled regularly – an additional expense (appx. $20-$40 or so each time) and the particulate traps add a new layer of maintenance – and thus, expense.

No one really knows, either, how these systems – and the diesel engines themselves – will hold up over the long haul, or under severe conditions such as extreme cold/heat.

* Diesels cost more “up front” than gas engines -

I recently test drove a diesel-powered version of the 2011 Chevy Silverado 2500 HD equipped with the optional Duramax diesel V-8. Selecting this engine (and the mandatory heavy-duty transmission that it’s paired with) added nearly $10,000 to the price of the truck. In a passenger car like the VW Jetta TDI, choosing the diesel over the gas engine adds about $2,500 to the sticker price.

The much higher up-front costs will take many years of driving to wash away in the form of at-the-pump savings on fuel – unless, of course, gas prices shoot up again to $4 (or more) per gallon. Which they very well could. 

In which case,  everything changes. In a world of $4 or $5 per gallon regular unleaded, a diesel vehicle that gets 15-2- percent better mileage than a gas equivalent could work off the higher up-front costs in as little as a year or two of driving.   

Throw it in the Woods?

Share Button

  8 comments for “Diesel Pros… and Cons

  1. clover
    November 20, 2010 at 2:14 am

    Gasoline type engines probably have more fuel sources used today than diesels do. There is gasoline, ethenol, hydrogen just among the few.
    Not very many people would be able to use deep frying grease for their diesel engines. All of the frying grease in the US would not be enough to power the vehicles in a small town. Yes there are a handfull that already use it in their engines but there are not enough fast food places.

    • November 20, 2010 at 10:50 am

      Well, sort of. Yes, a gas engine can burn alcohol – but it has to be extensively modified to do so. The fuel is corrosive and requires different seals, rubber gaskets/hoses and so on. Also the A/F ratio must be altered.

      Hydrogen requires complete re-engineering – and major expense.

      Diesels, on the other hand, can readily use any type of vegetable oil – canola, peanut, etc. – with minimal mods (mainly, a preheater to keep the fuel from congealing).

      Keep in mind that gasoline is much more refined than diesel; this is one of the reasons why the military prefers diesel (and kerosene).

    • Jinx Fogle
      June 19, 2013 at 3:29 pm

      Ethanol is such a waste of money and resources. Ethanol wastes energy, ground water and corn. The price of meat has doubled because ADM uses 55% of American corn to make the wasteful ethanol. I saw best cut and quality of steak for sale at the store for $28.00 a pound, because the feed corn was used to make polluting ethanol. ADM succeeds because of graft, I mean political donations to the right people. I know of which I speak, I have spent the last 30 years in the environmental industry.

  2. Derek Pivnick
    March 23, 2013 at 2:42 pm

    Do turbo-diesel engines require diesel engine oil or will regular motor oil suffice, and is synthetic or conventional the way to go?

    • March 23, 2013 at 3:28 pm

      Hi Derek,

      Emphatic yes! It is very important to use diesel-specific oil in a diesel engine. For example, Shell Rotella T. Never – ever – use standard/gas-engine oil in a diesel engine.

      • Derek Pivnick
        March 23, 2013 at 9:57 pm

        Thank you!

    • Mithrandir
      March 23, 2013 at 3:59 pm

      Oil for Diesels have certain qualities that are specific for diesel engines.

      One quality is the ability to keep soot in suspension and not deposit in the engine.

      From Fred’s TDI Club:

      Oils that lack the CG-4 or CH-4 rating don’t have the same level of anti-foaming and soot-dispersing capability. The best quality diesel-engine oils deal with it and render the soot as harmless to the engine as possible. Oils that don’t meet the CG-4 or CH-4 ratings can’t handle as much soot, so you need to change them sooner.

      • Derek Pivnick
        March 23, 2013 at 9:58 pm

        Thanks!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *